Pizza Domo, located in Hartsdale at 1 South Central Ave., closed its doors and put up a "for sale" sign as of Saturday, May 18.
The eatery had served a wide variety of pies with plenty of toppings, including buffalo chicken, meat lovers, and the "Gran Mama's" pizza with mozzarella, garlic, basil, and parmesan.
The pizza had been so well-received that the restaurant had collected plenty of five-star reviews on its Yelp page, including a write-up by Fran L. of Hartsdale written after their closure: "Miss you guys you are the best...The pizza I'm told is outstanding and can't wait for you to come back."
The pizzeria's owners did not reveal more information about the closure.
The eatery's demise prompted several disappointed comments on social media.
"I'm very sad. Always pleasant and great to chat with," wrote Angela C. in one Facebook post.
"Oh no, they were my favorite!" commented Stacie C.
Click here to follow Daily Voice Mount Pleasant and receive free news updates.